Martinsville Commonwealth’s Attorney Andrew Hall has announced that he will request a special prosecutor be appointed to investigate further the case involving former city manager Aretha Ferrell-Benavides. Just 24 hours earlier, Hall told the Bulletin that the heavily redacted report he had received from Sands Anderson would result in “a hamstrung investigation from the start.” We asked Hall on Friday what had changed. On Aug. 18, Hall had a virtual meeting with the attorneys of Sands Anderson and confirmed that they had created a report based on their investigation. “We requested a copy of the report and any evidence that it was based on,” Hall wrote. “Sands Anderson stated that they would need further clarification from the City Council.” On Aug. 26, city council voted again to “release to the Commonwealth’s Attorney printed versions of the report that deal with any criminal activity so that the Commonwealth’s Attorney may take action as necessary.” “We subsequently received a heavily redacted report by Sands Anderson,” Hall wrote. “We again requested that we receive the un-redacted report and any evidence that it was based on. As of today [Friday], these items have not been provided to us.”
Pity Richmond Circuit Court Judge Claire G. Cardwell and the taxpayers of Richmond. Watching lawyers Jimmy Robinson of Ogletree Deakins and Sarah Robb of Sarah Robb Law spar in Cardwell’s courtroom on Aug. 25 made me wish I could nominate Cardwell for a local version of the Nobel Peace Prize. The case before Cardwell concerns whether Connie Clay, a former City of Richmond Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) officer, was fired in retaliation for raising legal concerns about how her bosses in City Hall were handling FOIA requests. The Connie Clay case provides an object lesson on the high price Richmond has paid, both literally and figuratively, for years. It also provides an opportunity for Richmond’s new mayor to set a new tone for city government, a tone that emphasizes transparency and a respect for a citizen’s right to know what city government is doing. Style Weekly
“Democracies die behind closed doors.” ~ U.S. District Judge Damon Keith, 2002