2009 Sunshine Week survey about public attitudes toward government secrecy
Graphics for this survey and other FOI issues are available from McClatchy-Tribune for use during Sunshine Week. See www.sunshineweek.org.
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT STILL VIEWED AS SECRETIVE; PUBLIC SUPPORTS PRESIDENT'S DIRECTIVE ON TRANSPARENCY
Washington, D.C. -- For the first time in four years, public opinion about government secrecy has leveled off, although more than seven in 10 adults still consider the federal government to be secretive, according to the 2009 Sunshine Week survey by Scripps Howard News Service and Ohio University.
Since 2006, the percentage of adults who believe the federal government to be somewhat or very secretive has grown steadily; from 62 percent in 2006 to 74 percent in 2008. The latest survey finds 73 percent characterizing federal government as secretive.
This mood is perhaps buoyed by the nearly eight in 10 adults who think President Obama's Freedom of Information directive calling for a presumption of disclosure is the right thing to do.
"Trust in government has been on the decline for some time in the United States. The previous administration's disclosure policies certainly contributed to public skepticism," said Jerry Miller, director of the Scripps Survey Research Center at Ohio University. "People now appear more optimistic, but still guarded, about President Obama and the current administration's disclosure practices under the Freedom of Information Act."
As in previous years' surveys, people see their state and local governments as more open than the federal system. At the state level, 54 percent view government as open, 44 percent as secretive. People also are more trusting of local public officials. More than half, 56 percent, say their local government is very or somewhat open, with 44 percent rating it as very or somewhat open.
"The more open our government, the more inclusive the processes that impact our everyday lives," noted Rich Boehne, president and chief executive officer of The E.W. Scripps Co.
Two-thirds of adults (67 percent) say they've heard of the federal Freedom of Information Act, and when told about it, even more (77 percent) think it is a good law. However, hardly anyone surveyed had ever used it. Nine in 10 adults (94 percent) have never requested information using a FOIA request. None of this, of course, dulls their skepticism about compliance with the law: 61 percent say they believe the federal government only sometimes, rarely or never obeys FOIA law.
"It's heartening there is a reversal in the downward trend of public confidence in the openness of the federal government," said Andy Alexander, co-chair of the American Society of Newspaper Editor's FOI Committee.
"But it's sobering to note that more than half of those surveyed said they still believe their government only sometimes, rarely or never abides by disclosure requirements mandated by law," added Alexander, who is ombudsman at The Washington Post.
The survey of 946 adults was conducted by telephone from Feb. 16 through March 11 by the Scripps Survey Research Center at Ohio University under a grant from the Scripps Howard Foundation. The survey has a margin of error of about 4 percentage points.
The survey has been commissioned by ASNE for Sunshine Week since 2006, Sunshine Week is a non-partisan open government initiative led by ASNE, with print, online and broadcast media; public officials; civic groups and non-profit organizations; public and special libraries; educators and students; religious leaders; and others. It is primarily funded by a grant from the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation.
****
The following are select findings from the survey.
Trends in opinion of federal government secrecy since 2006:
Here are some questions about whether you feel government in America is open and transparent or whether you think government is closed and secretive. How about the federal government based in Washington, D.C.?
2006 2007 2008 2009
Very open 5 7 4 5
Somewhat open 28 18 16 19
Somewhat secretive 40 32 30 33
Very secretive 22 37 44 40
*****
Here are some questions about whether you feel government in America is open and transparent or whether you think government is closed and secretive. When talking about the local government in your community, do you think local government is very open, somewhat open, somewhat secretive or very secretive?
Very Open 11
Somewhat Open 46
Somewhat Secretive 31
Very Secretive 12
Don't Know/Other Response 0
How about your state government? Is it is very open, somewhat open, somewhat secretive or very secretive?
Very Open 7
Somewhat Open 37
Somewhat Secretive 38
Very Secretive 16
Don't Know/Other Response 2
How about the federal government based in Washington, D.C.?
Very Open 5
Somewhat Open 19
Somewhat Secretive 33
Very Secretive 40
Don't Know/Other Response 3
Have you ever heard of a federal law called the Freedom of Information Act?
Yes 67
No 32
Don’t know 1
This law is meant to allow the American people see what information the federal government has obtained about them or about issues they are interested in. Have you ever requested information under the Freedom of Information Act?
Yes 6
No 94
Don’t know 0
As best as you can tell, do you think the Freedom of Information Act is a good law or not a good law?
Good Law 77
Not a Good Law 8
Don’t know/Other response 15
How often do you think the federal government obeys this law and allows people to see information they are entitled to see. Does the federal government always obey this law, usually obey this law, only sometimes obey it, rarely obey it or never obey this law?
Always Obeys 4
Usually Obeys 23
Only Sometimes Obeys 42
Rarely Obeys 16
Never Obeys 3
Don't Know/Other Response 12
President Obama on his first day in office said he wants to usher in a new era of open government. He ordered all federal agencies to adopt what he calls a 'presumption in favor of disclosure' when handling requests under the Freedom of Information Act. Do you thing he is doing the right thing or not in giving this order or not?
Yes, Doing the Right Thing 79
No, Not Doing the Right Thing 9
Don't Know/Other Response 12
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT STILL VIEWED AS SECRETIVE; PUBLIC SUPPORTS PRESIDENT'S DIRECTIVE ON TRANSPARENCY
Washington, D.C. -- For the first time in four years, public opinion about government secrecy has leveled off, although more than seven in 10 adults still consider the federal government to be secretive, according to the 2009 Sunshine Week survey by Scripps Howard News Service and Ohio University.
Since 2006, the percentage of adults who believe the federal government to be somewhat or very secretive has grown steadily; from 62 percent in 2006 to 74 percent in 2008. The latest survey finds 73 percent characterizing federal government as secretive.
This mood is perhaps buoyed by the nearly eight in 10 adults who think President Obama's Freedom of Information directive calling for a presumption of disclosure is the right thing to do.
"Trust in government has been on the decline for some time in the United States. The previous administration's disclosure policies certainly contributed to public skepticism," said Jerry Miller, director of the Scripps Survey Research Center at Ohio University. "People now appear more optimistic, but still guarded, about President Obama and the current administration's disclosure practices under the Freedom of Information Act."
As in previous years' surveys, people see their state and local governments as more open than the federal system. At the state level, 54 percent view government as open, 44 percent as secretive. People also are more trusting of local public officials. More than half, 56 percent, say their local government is very or somewhat open, with 44 percent rating it as very or somewhat open.
"The more open our government, the more inclusive the processes that impact our everyday lives," noted Rich Boehne, president and chief executive officer of The E.W. Scripps Co.
Two-thirds of adults (67 percent) say they've heard of the federal Freedom of Information Act, and when told about it, even more (77 percent) think it is a good law. However, hardly anyone surveyed had ever used it. Nine in 10 adults (94 percent) have never requested information using a FOIA request. None of this, of course, dulls their skepticism about compliance with the law: 61 percent say they believe the federal government only sometimes, rarely or never obeys FOIA law.
"It's heartening there is a reversal in the downward trend of public confidence in the openness of the federal government," said Andy Alexander, co-chair of the American Society of Newspaper Editor's FOI Committee.
"But it's sobering to note that more than half of those surveyed said they still believe their government only sometimes, rarely or never abides by disclosure requirements mandated by law," added Alexander, who is ombudsman at The Washington Post.
The survey of 946 adults was conducted by telephone from Feb. 16 through March 11 by the Scripps Survey Research Center at Ohio University under a grant from the Scripps Howard Foundation. The survey has a margin of error of about 4 percentage points.
The survey has been commissioned by ASNE for Sunshine Week since 2006, Sunshine Week is a non-partisan open government initiative led by ASNE, with print, online and broadcast media; public officials; civic groups and non-profit organizations; public and special libraries; educators and students; religious leaders; and others. It is primarily funded by a grant from the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation.
****
The following are select findings from the survey.
Trends in opinion of federal government secrecy since 2006:
Here are some questions about whether you feel government in America is open and transparent or whether you think government is closed and secretive. How about the federal government based in Washington, D.C.?
2006 2007 2008 2009
Very open 5 7 4 5
Somewhat open 28 18 16 19
Somewhat secretive 40 32 30 33
Very secretive 22 37 44 40
*****
Here are some questions about whether you feel government in America is open and transparent or whether you think government is closed and secretive. When talking about the local government in your community, do you think local government is very open, somewhat open, somewhat secretive or very secretive?
Very Open 11
Somewhat Open 46
Somewhat Secretive 31
Very Secretive 12
Don't Know/Other Response 0
How about your state government? Is it is very open, somewhat open, somewhat secretive or very secretive?
Very Open 7
Somewhat Open 37
Somewhat Secretive 38
Very Secretive 16
Don't Know/Other Response 2
How about the federal government based in Washington, D.C.?
Very Open 5
Somewhat Open 19
Somewhat Secretive 33
Very Secretive 40
Don't Know/Other Response 3
Have you ever heard of a federal law called the Freedom of Information Act?
Yes 67
No 32
Don’t know 1
This law is meant to allow the American people see what information the federal government has obtained about them or about issues they are interested in. Have you ever requested information under the Freedom of Information Act?
Yes 6
No 94
Don’t know 0
As best as you can tell, do you think the Freedom of Information Act is a good law or not a good law?
Good Law 77
Not a Good Law 8
Don’t know/Other response 15
How often do you think the federal government obeys this law and allows people to see information they are entitled to see. Does the federal government always obey this law, usually obey this law, only sometimes obey it, rarely obey it or never obey this law?
Always Obeys 4
Usually Obeys 23
Only Sometimes Obeys 42
Rarely Obeys 16
Never Obeys 3
Don't Know/Other Response 12
President Obama on his first day in office said he wants to usher in a new era of open government. He ordered all federal agencies to adopt what he calls a 'presumption in favor of disclosure' when handling requests under the Freedom of Information Act. Do you thing he is doing the right thing or not in giving this order or not?
Yes, Doing the Right Thing 79
No, Not Doing the Right Thing 9
Don't Know/Other Response 12
